a post talking about a woman being called a jerk

The pressure to have kids is still enormous despite the fact that more and more Americans are opting for childfree lifestyles. It’s no wonder that many couples feel stressed out by inconsiderate and nosy family members and friends who never miss a chance to ask that annoying question.

“Friends and family are causing us constant stress about having a baby soon but it’s obviously something we can’t control. We only wished that they’d stop but to no avail,” the woman who’s been married for 6 years wrote in this recent post on r/AITA.

The author said she carries the pregnancy Jar with her whenever she is with friends and family. “Every time someone asks about when my husband and I are gonna have a baby, I pull my Jar out and ask them to drop a dollar in there for asking.” The author said it actually works.

Last week, family drama over the “Pregnancy Jar” blew up after the author’s brother asked you-know-what. To find out how the drama evolved, read below, and be sure to share your thoughts in the comments.


A woman asked if she didn’t go too far with her “Pregnancy Jar” that she uses to take a dollar from anyone who asks when she’s having kids.


A question like “when are you having a baby?” is something many women would do anything for. Many of us have experienced it multiple times. We spoke with Susan Petang, a certified divorce coach and creator of “The Quiet Zone Coaching,” who teaches people how to stop feeling overwhelmed and start waking up happy again.

“It can be super annoying when others (family or not!) continually ask when you’re going to have kids get married, or something else that they think you should be doing,” Susan said and added that “no, it’s none of their business.” Having said that, the life coach thinks the “jar” idea is “IMHO, a little jerky, and provokes arguments and bad feelings.” She explained: “How would you feel if you asked someone a question – thinking that it’s perfectly innocent – and they whip out a jar, demanding a dollar?”


“Let me ask you this: Why are they asking in the first place? Is it because they know you want kids, and are concerned about your happiness? Is it because they’re just nosy or is it because they don’t have the social skills to know that it’s an inappropriate question?”

Susan argues that “trying to understand WHY someone is doing something annoying doesn’t justify their behavior, but putting yourself in someone else’s shoes for a moment helps YOU be less annoyed.” She added: “you can even think to yourself, ‘Wow, it’s really sad that they don’t understand how annoying that question is.’”

Susan reminds everyone that other people are going to do what they are going to do. “We have no control over their behavior. You’re right, your Nosy Aunt Rosie shouldn’t be asking you these questions – but she just did.” The life coach argues that “our expectations of others aren’t going to change the weather on Jupiter, so don’t get all bristly when people ask stupid or nosy questions – we can’t control them, but we can control ourselves, and our responses.”



Susan suggests that if you ever get this question, shut them down gently. “Address the intention rather than the question. For example, the woman in the story could say to her brother, ‘That’s something I love about you – you’re so concerned about my happiness!’ (Note that she hasn’t answered the nosy question.)”

Susan added: “Another great response would be, ‘You seem like you really want us to have a baby!’ Then let him explain his question. You can also come right out and ask, ‘Why do you want to know?’”

Susan wants readers to make sure their responses come from a place of love. “It’s a better way to keep the peace and be a kind human being. (I hope she doesn’t get a kick out of being a jerk!)”


Many people said that the idea of a pregnancy Jar was great.

But what happens if the other person keeps pressing, and won’t let the question go? Susan argues that there are two ways of shutting that down. “The first is to agree with them: ‘You’re right, we should really get right on that! Thanks for the reminder!’ or, ‘You’re right, now you’ve given us something to think about. Thanks for your concern!’ If you agree with them, there’s nothing to argue with.”

“The second is to set a limit using the XYZ formula: ‘When you do X, I feel Y, and I’d like Z.’ This should be your last resort after you’ve tried being kind and they still won’t stop asking.”

The tone is everything, whichever way you choose to shut them down. “This could be a super hostile way to deal with someone, too, depending on how you say it – so make sure you’re being as kind as possible until the other person is being nasty or hostile,” Susan explained. “An example would be, ‘When you ask us about having children, it makes me sad and angry because it just hasn’t happened for us yet. I’d like to change the subject,’ or, ‘It sounds like you’re really interested in something that, to us, is very personal. I feel upset when you ask about it, so let’s talk about something else.’”


People questioned the author’s method.