A Sequel That Dares to Defy Expectations
Just when fans thought they had seen it all, “What If…? Season 2” spins a new tale with its fifth episode, boldly titled “What If… Captain Carter Fought the Hydra Stomper?” In a twist of irony, the Watcher himself, typically averse to sequels, opens the episode with a nod to the continuity of Captain Carter’s journey. This episode builds on the narrative of “What If… Captain Carter Were the First Avenger?” and “What If… The Watcher Broke his Oath?”, showcasing Captain Carter (Hayley Atwell) in an alternate Battle of New York and scenes reminiscent of The Winter Soldier.
Recapping Episode 5: A New Yet Familiar Battle
The Hydra Stomper Takes Center Stage
In a compelling twist, Steve Rogers (Josh Keaton), inside the HYDRA Stomper, assumes the role traditionally held by the Winter Soldier. The narrative weaves a complex web, with Steve inadvertently becoming a key HYDRA operative. Meanwhile, Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan) emerges as the Secretary of State, playing a crucial role in a high-stakes S.H.I.E.L.D. operation.
A Journey to the Red Room
Peggy’s mission takes an unexpected turn as she, Steve, and Natasha Romanoff (Lake Bell) end up on a remote Scottish island. The Red Room, a pivotal location in Steve’s brainwashing, is revealed to be in Sokovia, disguised as an American suburbia—a classic trope revisited with a modern twist.
Confrontation and Subterfuge in Sokovia
Betrayal and Battle
The episode escalates as Melina Vostokoff (Rachel Weisz) from Black Widow reveals Steve’s role as a double agent. This leads to an intense confrontation between Peggy and Steve, Natasha against her “family,” and a battle against an army of animatronics. It’s a sequence that combines emotional depth with thrilling action.
A Heroic Sacrifice
In a heartrending climax, Peggy manages to break through Steve’s programming, leading to his self-sacrificing decision to destroy the Red Room. Natasha’s quick thinking ensures that Melina doesn’t escape the fallout, marking an end to the immediate threat.
Looking Ahead: What Lies Beyond for Captain Carter?
An Uncertain Future
The episode concludes with a sense of uncertainty for Peggy, hinting at her involvement in the upcoming episode. The Watcher’s surprise at Peggy’s sudden transportation through a mysterious portal sets the stage for what appears to be an adventure in a Marvel 1602 setting, where she meets Nick Fury and Wanda Maximoff in Elizabethan attire.
Subverting Expectations
In a departure from the series’ norm, “What If…?” Season 2 Episode 5 offers a fresh perspective on familiar characters and stories. It blends action, emotion, and a touch of the unexpected, leaving fans eagerly anticipating what’s next in this ever-evolving anthology.
As the series continues to explore the vast multiverse, it remains clear that “What If…?” is not just about reimagining stories but about delving into the depths of characters and narratives, offering a unique and captivating experience to Marvel fans. Each episode is a testament to the limitless possibilities within the Marvel Universe, and Episode 5 stands as a shining example of the series’ ability to surprise, delight, and engage its audience.
