A recent Reddit post has ignited a heated discussion among fans of One Piece anime, shedding light on concerns regarding its adaptation from the original manga. The post, made by a passionate fan under the username u/kjm6351, criticizes the anime’s pacing, episode-to-chapter ratio, and animation quality, prompting a wave of responses from fellow enthusiasts.
One Piece anime & manga’s mismatch
In the post, u/kjm6351 expresses frustration over what they perceive as a significant disparity between the number of episodes in the anime and the corresponding chapters in the manga. They argue that the anime’s practice of adapting less than a chapter per episode, sometimes even as little as 10-15 pages, results in padded content that detracts from the overall viewing experience. This, they claim, contributes to the misconception that One Piece is far longer and more daunting than it is.
Comment
byu/calculatingaffection from discussion
inCharacterRant
Furthermore, u/kjm6351 suggests a more streamlined approach to adapting the series, proposing that the first six sagas could have been covered in fewer seasons, reducing the total number of episodes while maintaining narrative integrity. They also criticize the animation quality, comparing it unfavorably to other popular shonen series like Naruto and Bleach, particularly highlighting the lackluster fight sequences until the Wano arc.
The post garnered significant attention from the One Piece anime fans with many users echoing similar sentiments about the anime’s pacing issues and animation quality. Some fans expressed disappointment over missed opportunities for filler content and adaptation of cover stories from the manga, which could have enriched the viewing experience without detracting from the main storyline.
Comment
byu/calculatingaffection from discussion
inCharacterRant
However, not all responses were critical of the One Piece anime. Some users defended the series, acknowledging its flaws but highlighting its strengths, such as character development, world-building, and memorable moments. They argued that while the anime may have its shortcomings, it still holds value for fans who enjoy experiencing the story through animation.
Overall, the post and ensuing discussion underscore the passionate and diverse opinions within the One Piece anime fanbase regarding the anime adaptation. While some fans advocate for improvements in pacing and animation, others continue to find enjoyment in the series despite its perceived flaws.
